This is Part 4 of my ongoing “Philosophy of Work” series. Each article can be read standalone, but together they form a cohesive telling of my view of the world.
The Promo Committee at the End of the World (this article)
If you enjoy these sorts of meta-reflections on working in tech, then you’ll enjoy this blog. Every article will always be freely available; subscribe to get e-mail updates. Paid tiers are also available if you want to support my work!
Nuclear war jockeying, planes grounded nationwide, the market is collapsing, seemingly anything with a CPU is compromised, governments are issuing instructions to stockpile food and water for suspiciously long periods of time, AI is upending entire professions, and somehow, SOMEONE will walk into my office next week and ask me earnestly, “So, do you think I’m ready for promo?”
Lord save us all.
Humor aside, these things matter to people. A LOT. I’ve had employees burst into tears when I told them their promo had been rejected. These are often people I know and admire, people who once seemed to derive enormous satisfaction from their work, and yet, they’re miserable. They don’t really inhabit the “time between promotions”; it passes in a blur of late nights and missed social engagements, and they seem only to take pleasure in the milestone itself. Yet that time in between is the majority of their life!
I’ve seen this “living dead” phenomenon show up in lots of different ways. Someone’s passion project gets canceled, and they become permanently embittered, never bringing their whole self to work ever again. Or the person who sees work as little more than a paycheck, with life happening “elsewhere.” The pathology is the same for all of the above: people latch onto an outcome they believe will make them happy (a title, a wage, a particular project, an alternative career), but are completely miserable while pursuing that goal. Shouldn’t your life’s aspiration be…IDK…exciting!?
Sometimes the causes are perfectly explainable—a broken promise, an abusive manager—other times it’s hard to identify anything objectively wrong. They have interesting work, talented colleagues, and good compensation, but the thought of doing it all again tomorrow fills them with dread.
I find this terribly sad.
Most of us spend a third of our adult lives working (who are we kidding? As software people, it’s more like a full 50%). That’s an awful lot of time to spend waiting for 5 o’clock, Friday, retirement, or some imagined future when everything finally falls into place.
What bothers me most is that much of this suffering may be unnecessary. What if you didn’t have to change your life to start living it? What if the journey could be as rich as the destination?
The Many Ways to Miss Your Own Life
I’ve come to recognize 4 patterns of misery. These aren’t exhaustive or mutually exclusive, but I suspect you’ll recognize a few familiar faces…and maybe even your own.
The Proxy Chaser
Species Typica: The Promo Obsessive
Motto: My life will begin when I acquire something.
The Proxy Chaser has an all-consuming obsession with something adjacent to the work itself: a promotion, professional status, architectural purity, organizational influence, whatever.
The most common member of this genus, and the star of our article today, is the Promo Obsessive. They care little for the specific project, just that it “meets the bar for L+1.” They are defensive in every interaction and (unintentionally) send the signal they aren’t interested in collaboration. It’s critical that everything they do be seen as THEIR IDEA and THEIR IDEAS ARE GOOD, lest the promo committee get the false impression that the real genius is someone else.
Managing these creatures is no less frustrating. You will offer them real, honest feedback on missing skills…and they will accept it! (surprise!!) Except, not really. You will tell them that their peer influence needs work and they’ll be extra active in team chat, use lots of smiley faces in code reviews 😊😊😊, and write a design doc for someone else’s project. Literally 7 days later, in your next 1:1, they will go, “See? I’m very good at influence! So what’s next?” No deeper engagement, no understanding of the feedback behind the feedback, no admission of fault, no actual development of new skills; it’s just box-checking all the way down.
Their ambition isn’t inherently problematic, but the pursuit has subsumed their ability to engage deeply and take pleasure in the work itself—in a word, they are not present. Sometimes they have been chasing for so long that they don’t even realize they’re doing it. The simulacrum has fully replaced the original article.
The Quiet Quitter
Species Typica: The Ticket Monkey
Motto: My real life happens somewhere else.
The Quiet Quitter’s engagement with work begins and ends with completing assigned tasks—that’s it. They get the job done (often quite competently) but bring very little of themselves to it.
Don’t confuse this with working 9-to-5 or refusing to take on additional unpaid responsibilities; those are healthy boundaries. The real defining characteristic is a lack of inner engagement—they have closed themselves off from both the work and their coworkers. At more junior levels, this looks like the “Ticket Monkey” archetype: they attend standup, close their tickets, and go home. In the managerial ranks, this looks like running meetings, completing performance reviews, and maintaining project plans without expressing much conviction about what their teams are actually doing. They rarely challenge bad ideas, develop new approaches, or take the initiative unless someone explicitly asks them to.
Some are perfectly delightful people. You might never suspect anything was wrong unless you’d seen what they were capable of when they were genuinely interested.
The Shadow Founder is a particularly vexing subspecies: someone who reserves their curiosity and enthusiasm for a startup, creative pursuit, hobby, or some other future in which they’ll finally be doing what they love. What makes them so confounding is that they are fully aware of and in tune with the human need for fulfillment and purpose…but then lobotomize themselves for half the day!
On one hand, Quiet Quitters are meeting expectations…can you really complain? On the other hand, they have reserved fulfillment and engagement for the time they own 100%, leaving their primary 40-hour-a-week job completely hollowed out. Their work has become an endless loop of unfulfilling minutiae, and the resulting semi-depressive state bleeds through in many interactions, ruining the vibe and making it hard for others to engage fully.
The Burned Believer
Species Typica: The Jaded Veteran
Motto: I cannot engage until the world makes good on what it owes me.
Unlike the Quiet Quitter, who silently slips into passivity, the Burned Believer is loudly disengaged.
They once had a moral or even familial covenant with the company—treating the corporate mission as their personal identity. Then a layoff, a killed project, a broken promise, or some other corporate indignity shattered their faith in the enterprise. They care too much to let it go and collect a paycheck like a Quiet Quitter, and they can’t distract themselves by going for promo like a Proxy Chaser (in fact, they actively mock the promo game).
The most familiar member of this genus is the Jaded Veteran.
Jaded Veterans have been around long enough to accumulate a mile-long list of grievances. We internally cheer when they ask the hard question or call BS during an all-hands Q&A, but we also can’t seem to get through a single conversation without triggering an emotional landmine over some past offense. Your enthusiasm for a promising new initiative wilts in the face of their endless antipathy for The Way Things Are™.
More inconspicuous but just as disengaged are the Guarded Hearts. They used to care once, then they took an arrow to the knee. PMs keep changing their minds, causing constant rework; your manager delays a much-needed refactor; an impassioned proposal you wrote falls on deaf ears; a Director overrides your technical judgment; a promo or rating you thought you earned got denied. It doesn’t really matter what caused it; the Guarded Heart got burned badly enough to decide they weren’t going to make the mistake of caring that much ever again.
The uniting trait for all the Burned Believers is that they are so preoccupied with nurturing past grievances that they miss when things change for the better, and therefore never fully experience or benefit from the opportunity in front of them.
The Displaced Artisan
Species Typica: The AI Doomer
Motto: I cannot embrace what comes next without surrendering who I am.
The Displaced Artisan once found enormous pleasure in writing software: elegant abstractions, carefully choreographed systems, ingenious algorithms, and the satisfaction of mastering a difficult craft.
Then AI changed the medium of their work—we stopped working with clay and started sculpting in marble.
They’re not necessarily Luddites. They recognize that engineering still matters, but it’s shifting toward specifications, context, prompts, loops, and directing machines that write code instead…but this new medium doesn’t inspire the same intellectual and emotional attachment that code did.
The Artisans often can’t quite explain why they feel this way—they point to production outages or rising tech debt and go, “see?! I knew this was bad!” but that isn’t really what was bothering them. As such, many are quietly wallowing in shame and self-doubt that they can’t make the leap to the next big thing. It doesn’t help that their employer is probably celebrating a 400% increase in PR throughput and creating a suite of perverse incentives that encourage slop-cannon behavior, seemingly confirming their worst fears about the death of craft and whatnot.
The Artisan hasn’t lost their curiosity or capacity for mastery. They’ve become attached to a particular expression of those qualities and are struggling to find fulfillment in what comes next: the substrate mattered.
There But for the Grace of God
These aren’t just a bunch of burnouts, skidmarks, and assorted oddballs. Well-adjusted people fall into these modes of thinking every day.
I know plenty of excellent senior engineers who, until recently, were perfectly content being senior engineers. They’d mastered their craft, contributed meaningfully to their teams, and established enough professional security to enjoy rich, balanced lives outside work. Then came layoffs, AI-driven restructuring, and a job market increasingly perceived as favoring Staff+ engineers. Suddenly, people who’d previously been focused on living their best lives found themselves worrying about basic security. Now they’re Proxy Chasers who, a year or two earlier, might not have cared about promo at all.
Or perhaps you’ve poured yourself into a job, consistently going above and beyond, only to discover that the extra effort yielded little recognition, advancement, or remuneration. Meanwhile, your employer continued ratcheting up expectations. Eventually, you decided to do precisely what you were paid to do and save your enthusiasm for the parts of life where you could actually exercise some control over the outcome. Congratulations, you’ve become a Quiet Quitter.
Maybe you spent two years building something you genuinely loved, only to watch it get canceled after an executive reorganization. You’d invested enormous energy in the work and imagined what it might eventually become…then someone moved a box on an org chart, and the whole thing disappeared. The next time somebody asks you to get excited about a new strategic initiative, you smile politely and wait to see whether it survives the quarter. Welcome to the Burned Believer Club.
None of these people began as strange defects. Their dispositions developed in response to astonishingly common experiences, and then were ossified by this really toxic idea that has become a trope in career coaching: fulfillment is something we find only in the right circumstances. We’re encouraged to discover our passion, find our calling, seek out the right company, identify a compatible manager, and pursue opportunities that align with our interests.
But this way of thinking can become a trap. It encourages us to regard fulfillment as something conferred by our circumstances, rather than something we can cultivate through our relationship with them. When the conditions aren’t right, we conclude that there’s little to be done except wait for something better.
I recognize this tendency in myself.
For most of my career, I told everyone that I loved engineering management because work had saved me many times over. I found enormous self-worth and self-confidence in learning, creating, solving difficult problems, and I wanted to build organizations where everyone could experience some measure of that same fulfillment.
My closest friends, meanwhile, knew I was fucking miserable.
The reality of senior management was 12-hour days of contentious meetings, negotiating priorities, resolving interpersonal conflicts, and trying to convince people to cooperate long enough for my teams to get something useful done.
Too often, the people on the other side of these conversations seemed preoccupied with defending their territory, protecting their professional standing, or ensuring that their own ideas emerged victorious. What should have been a joint search for truth became a prolonged corporate knife fight. I increasingly resented having to deal with them.
Eventually, I stopped trying so hard. The projects were staffed, the goals were set, performance reviews got done, and the basic machinery of management kept running. But I stopped looking around corners, anticipating impediments, developing my people, and seeking new ways to help my teams do exceptional work. I was fulfilling my responsibilities without bringing much of what had once made me good at the job.
The really embarrassing part is that I know these interactions don’t have to be miserable. There’s an entire craft to participatory decision-making—I literally blogged about it 6 years ago! I’ve studied these techniques, practiced them, and found enormous intellectual satisfaction in using them. Even the most contentious meeting can become a fascinating little laboratory in human reasoning and collective decision-making.
But somewhere along the way, I decided these people weren’t worth the investment. I stopped seeing them as interesting, capable individuals whose genius I might unlock and started treating them as obstacles to overcome.
The satisfaction I once found in management had been replaced by a desire to finish the work, secure the necessary outcomes, and get on with the parts of my life I still enjoyed. And so I became precisely the kind of person I’d spent years lamenting. I had become a Quiet Quitter.
How much larger your life would be if your self could become smaller in it; if you could really look at other men with common curiosity and pleasure; if you could see them walking as they are in their sunny selfishness and their virile indifference! You would begin to be interested in them, because they are not interested in you. You would break out of this tiny and tawdry theatre in which your own little plot is always played, and you would find yourself under a freer sky, in a street full of splendid strangers.
— G.K. Chesterton, Orthodoxy
Luckily, that isn’t the end of my story. I’ve since learned that even when we cannot choose our circumstances, we often retain more freedom in how we participate in those circumstances than we realize.
Having vs. Being
In his 1976 book To Have or To Be?, the philosopher and psychoanalyst Erich Fromm argues that human beings experience the world through two fundamentally different orientations: having and being.
The having orientation should feel familiar to all of us as members of a modern capitalist society. We spend much of our lives accumulating: money, property, professional status, authority, knowledge, credentials, and whatever else confers security or social legitimacy.
But Fromm’s argument is more subtle than a complaint about materialism. We can possess ideas, relationships, memories, experiences, and even our understanding of ourselves. The defining characteristic is our tendency to treat these things as objects we acquire and retain, rather than activities through which we participate in the world.
Imagine an engineer who decides to become an expert in Rust.
They meticulously study the language, complete courses, accumulate certifications, and eventually update their résumé to proudly advertise their newfound expertise. With sufficient dedication, they may even become a recognized authority in the field.
But why Rust?
Perhaps they’re fascinated by memory safety, type systems, and the possibility of constructing software in which entire categories of bugs can be eliminated by design. They’ve encountered a genuinely interesting problem and found a discipline that gives them new tools for understanding it. That’s the being mindset. Or perhaps Rust is merely a fashionable credential, a badge of technical sophistication they can display to prospective employers, colleagues, and potential mates (please DM me if Rust ever got you a date; I need to know if this is a thing). Replace Rust with Florp, the hot new programming language everyone’s talking about, and they’d pursue it with precisely the same enthusiasm. That’s the having mindset.
The distinction isn’t between studying hard and studying casually, nor does it depend on which student becomes a more capable Rust programmer in the end. Both might work equally hard…heck, both might want to earn more money and advance their careers. What distinguishes them is whether those goals have displaced their engagement with the activity itself. Only one is experiencing learning as an intrinsically rewarding activity.
This is the essential problem with the having orientation: our lives become organized around acquiring, retaining, and defending things that are supposed to make us fulfilled, while the activities through which we pursue them become increasingly instrumental. Fromm demonstrates how pervasive this problem is across faith, love, friendships, conversations, child-rearing, reminiscing, traveling, and even death.
And therein lies the common pathology of our four friends above: each has become so preoccupied with acquiring, preserving, or recovering something they believe essential to their fulfillment that they’ve lost the ability to enjoy the life they’re already living.
The being orientation offers another way to live, although even describing it is difficult. We live in a society so thoroughly organized around economic achievement and accumulation that our vocabulary for discussing human development is largely possessive. We gain experience, acquire skills, build relationships, establish credibility, and earn respect. You have a lover rather than are loving or practice love, compressing the beloved into a 2-dimensional object—a dead thing on your shelf rather than an ever-changing, rich, alive soul. Even our careers as technologists are described like some elaborate RPG progression system where we grind enough XP to unlock the next “level.”
So what the hell does it actually mean to be?
It’s to experience yourself as a living, thinking, feeling participant in the world; to give expression to one’s faculties, one’s talents, and wealth of human gifts; to grow, to flow out, transcend one’s ego, to give, to be interested, to be anything but listless—to engage with the world and the people in it, not because of what you might eventually get out of them, but because you are capable of doing so.
You don’t have to wait for a promotion, an appreciative manager, an interesting assignment, or some other favorable alignment of the corporate planets to begin doing any of these things. They’re capacities you already possess, and their exercise is itself a source of fulfillment.
This raises a rather interesting question, though. If being is fundamentally about exercising our faculties, doesn’t that describe just about everything we do? The engineer frantically preparing a promotion packet is exercising considerable ingenuity. The executive spending 12 hours arguing with colleagues is certainly exercising something (masochism?). Both are unquestionably busy, and both might come home thoroughly exhausted…but are they actually experiencing the kind of “activity” Fromm is talking about?
Activity vs. Passivity
We tend to equate activity with busyness. Someone who responds to 50 Slack messages and closes 20 Jira tickets has obviously had a very active day. Meanwhile, someone sitting quietly under a tree doing absolutely nothing is, well, doing absolutely nothing.
But this tells us practically nothing about whether either person is acting of their own volition.
Consider someone suffering from OCD. They may feel compelled to count their steps, repeat particular phrases, or perform elaborate private rituals, sometimes spending hours on activities they neither enjoy nor wish to continue. They’re unquestionably doing something, but their behavior is driven by an internal compulsion that can be extraordinarily difficult to resist or even articulate.
This illustrates a particularly extreme version of alienated activity: behavior governed by forces we don’t fully understand or control. These forces needn’t be pathological: our normal anxieties, ambitions, and insecurities can dictate our behavior just as effectively as our employers barking orders.
Spinoza made a similar distinction in his Ethics, separating acting from being acted upon. We are active when our behavior follows from our own nature and understanding—when we are, in his terminology, an adequate cause of our actions. We are passive when we’re governed by influences we don’t adequately understand.
Under this conception, someone consumed by ambition or resentment may be spectacularly busy while remaining fundamentally passive. Conversely, someone quietly investigating a difficult problem, or taking time to get to know their colleagues better over coffee, may be profoundly active. The defining characteristic of nonalienated, productive activity is that we experience ourselves as the authors of our actions, rather than merely responding to forces that dictate what we do.
It’s quite possible, then, to spend an entire working day producing economically valuable things without experiencing much productive activity whatsoever.
The Life You’re Already Living
Our capacity for curiosity, generosity, love, reason, artistic and intellectual creation is not a scarce resource that must be carefully rationed (lest we waste it on undeserving people or unworthy activities). On the contrary, such things grow through their exercise.
Our energy is finite, of course. We get tired, need rest, and have lives outside work. Nor is every encounter with a disagreeable colleague a profound opportunity for spiritual development (sometimes the guy is just an asshole). But even when our circumstances are far from ideal, there’s something to be gained from exercising these faculties for their own sake, regardless of whether the people around us appreciate the effort.
There’s a lovely metaphor attributed to Swiss painter and stained-glass artist Max Hunziker which I think makes the point in a single stroke (emphasis mine):
A blue glass appears to be blue when light shines through it because it absorbs all other colors and thus does not let them pass. This is to say, we call a glass “blue” precisely because it does not retain the blue waves. It is named not for what it possesses but for what it gives out.
I find this a rather beautiful way to think about a person. We’re accustomed to defining ourselves by what we’ve accumulated—our expertise, accomplishments, authority, possessions—but perhaps something more revealing lies in what we give expression to.
My father taught me something similar many years ago.
He ran his own business for over a decade before the 2008 financial crisis destroyed it. Without a college education, his options were limited, and he eventually took an hourly job working the shipping dock at a steel factory.
I remember asking him one day: How does he tolerate such a job? He’d spent years running his own business, making consequential decisions, and enjoying considerable autonomy. Now he was loading trucks and driving a forklift (admittedly, this is secretly every man’s dream).
His answer has stayed with me ever since. It doesn’t matter whether you’re loading trucks, sweeping floors, fixing machinery, or running a company. What matters is that you’re spending your life doing it. Those hours are yours, and they deserve respect. Whatever work is in front of you, you owe it to yourself to do it well.
He never once let his circumstances dim the light he gave off. My father eventually worked his way through nearly every level of that factory, ultimately becoming its Head of Production. It’s an extraordinary accomplishment, but his philosophy would have been just as valid if he’d spent the rest of his career on the shipping dock.
As I shared earlier, I’ve struggled to live up to that philosophy myself, particularly in recent years. I know perfectly well that there’s more satisfaction to be found in my current work than I’ve managed to discover. I’ve spent years studying and practicing the very skills that might help me find it. But knowing how to do something and being able to bring yourself to do it are apparently two different things. This is all to say: just because you’ve read this article does not mean you will suddenly be happy tomorrow. These are habits of mind that take practice, and I suspect I’ll be working on them for the rest of my life.
You may find that there’s an enormous amount of satisfaction waiting to be discovered in the work you’re already doing. Or you may decide, as I have, that you’ve reached the limits of what you can make of your present circumstances, and it’s time to change them. Either way, you should take responsibility for how you participate in your own life.
You are here. What are you saving yourself for?



I'm going to sit with this one for a while.
It's easy to compare what you get against what you give and feel that the most important thing is to keep the two in balance. Any fall in the receiving side justifies pulling back on the giving side. Not necessarily time or effort, but yourself. Your mental and emotional engagement.
It makes sense if you take an abstract, corporate view of your work. You're just finding the optimal output of the system. But what kind of person do you become in the process? How do you respond to people who hurt you? Can you live as a shell of yourself for most of the day and it not impact the rest of your life? Can you bring all of yourself again and again, disappointment after disappointment? Do you really have a choice? Lots of good things to think about.
I'll have to check out those books, though I can't promise I'll be smart enough to get much out of them.